13. Sermon Preached on Easter Monday 1539
By Bernardino Ochino da Siena
Translated by Patrick Colbourne OFM Cap
Translator’s note: This translation is based on the introduction, text and footnotes which were published by P. Costanzo Cargnoni O.F.M. Cap. in I Frati Cappuccini: Documenti e testimonianze dell primo secolo, Edizioni Frate Indovino, Perugia, vol III/1, pages 2255-2270. The only additions to the notes made by the translator are references to Francis of Assisi: The Early Documents, edited by Regis Armstrong, O.F.M. Cap., J. A. Wayne Hellmann, O.F.M. and William J. Short O.F.M. Conv., New York City Press, New York, London, Manila, for an English version of quotations from the Writings or Biographies of St Francis.
Introduction by Costanzo Cargnoni OFM Cap
The “good news” in this sermon is that Christ was full of “the utmost charity and love.” To demonstrate this Ochino makes use of the Gospel of the day that speaks about the disciples at Emmaus who were perplexed and sad on account of the death of the Master. He says that we have “to break open and bite through the crust of the literal meaning” of the word of God to extract its fertile spiritual meaning. It is not sufficient to stop at the literal meaning, at what is actually visible, but we should do what Mary did when “she ponders over exalted secrets” in her heart. He says that “it is not such a difficult thing to set aside the pleasures of the world in order to delight in Christ”. We should look at the cross, the poverty and Christ’s sufferings and then we will find out what real joy is. Ochino goes along with the two disciples as they are travelling along the road, by reconstructing, in his imagination, their sad conversation, with one not believing that Christ who had died on the cross was the Son of God, and the other, on the other hand, thinking about Christ’s life on earth, and recalling the many prophesies and looking back at the Sacred Scriptures and thereby discovering many reasons for believing that Christ really was the Son of God. At this point the Risen Christ comes up to them disguised as a pilgrim and joins in on the conversation. Ochino briefly relates the rest of the Gospel passage up to the invitation: Mane nobiscum, Domine. Christ, the pilgrim, provides the opportunity to make a comparison with the “spiritual soul” that ought to undertake a pilgrimage until it is enlightened by faith, until the “countless gifts received from God” have been revealed and a hymn of thanksgiving and burning love breaks out in the heart.
13. Sermon Preached on Easter Monday 1539 [1]
5758 Even though all of God’s works and accomplishments are evident, nevertheless, God’s wisdom, omnipotence, generosity, graces, virtues, happiness, charity and finally his abundant perfection is supremely evident in Christ. Therefore, I want to say a few words about today’s Gospel
[The disciples from Emmaus]
5759 Two of Christ’s disciples who were perplexed by Christ’s death and who were afraid that the Jews would persecute them because they had been Christ’s disciples, left the Holy City of Jerusalem and went to a village called Emmaus, about seven and a half miles from Jerusalem. They were talking about what had happened to their master. They thought that as they had lost their master that it was better to leave the Holy City and go to a small village. Christ joined them and remained with them until nightfall. Then the two disciples, even though they did not know him, pressed him to stay with them and so he stayed on. When they were sitting at the table, cognoverunt eum in fractione panis.
[The recognition of Christ in the breaking of bread]
Some think about gifts in a superficial manner, concentrating just on a particular gift and going no further and because they stop at that they do not profit from it and do not experience anything. It is necessary to break open and bite through the crust and not simply think about the benefit itself but also of the many treasures that it contains. Then one should consider who the benefactor is and how magnificent he is. You should think about yourself as the recipient of the gift and what a vile creature you are and how of all the things that God created on earth none has been as rebellious as mankind. Look at how the plants always obey the rules that God has given them. The rivers never turn back on their original course. The heavens and everything else never stop moving; only rational creatures do this by sinning against God who made them.
5760 Consider why the gift was given. It was certainly not given because you deserved it. It was only because of his burning love that you have received so many gifts, so many graces, such enlightenment and so many treasures. If you go through this analysis you will be forced to acknowledge that your benefactor was Christ, who was God.
Among us there are those who rely entirely on sense knowledge and who only see created things and stop at that without going any further. They are delighted by the created things that they can see on earth. They should not stop there but immediate break and eat bread, saying: God created all of this for us to use, so that it would be useful in supplying what we need. We ought to thank him for the many gifts and graces that he has given the human race. At this point you would begin to appreciate infinitely God’s omnipotence, wisdom and generosity so that when you have broken this bread you will come to know God.
Others contemplate God in natural phenomena and investigate what are the causes of things. However, they do not go beyond this kind of speculation. They do not rise up to heaven. Do not be like the worldly-wise who stop at created objects. You should carefully break this bread and firmly grasp that all of this was produced ab aeterno by God because of his omnipotence and generosity. By doing this you will come to the knowledge of God.
There are those among us who study the Sacred Scripture, the Old and the New Testaments, but do it superficially, focusing on the letter and only considering the events in the story. However, it is also necessary for you to take the characters apart as well as the events, making comparisons and thinking about how everything came to fulfilment in Christ and therefore how all of this was a clue through which we could come to know the truth.
5761 Among us there are some who contemplate Christ’s conception, his birth and his time in Egypt but only as natural, human events. However, they should break these up by contemplating where he had come from, and for what purpose. You will find that there was no other reason other than the heartfelt love that he had for us and then you will come to know God.
Praeterea, there are some who contemplate Christ on the cross, his suffering, the thorns, the nails and the lashes. However, you should break this bread, so that you can chew it and turn it over as Mary did when conservabat omnia verba haec, conferens in corde suo.
5762 It is not a big thing to put aside the pleasures of the world in order to take up what is pleasing to Christ since this is much greater and makes you desire to have more
Note that the disciples followed Christ because he was amiable, his words and what he preached was sweet and his conversation was so kind because they were still full of self-love, until the Holy Spirit came upon them and made them strong and sinless. However, up to that time they followed Christ for their own gratification. They were not following him for spiritual reasons, but because they experienced incomparable sweetness and inestimable fulfilment. However, as Christ came closer to his Passion, anxiety and suffering, they all lost faith in him, with some abandoning him, others taking flight, denying him or betraying him so that each one stepped back and did not follow him during his Passion, with the exception of Mary.
[The sad conversation along the road]
5763 When the two disciples who are featured in today’s Gospel lost Christ through his death, they became sad and melancholy because they had lost the spiritual pleasure and contentment they had experienced while Christ was with them. Weighed down with sadness they left the Holy City and went to Emmaus. As they were talking to each other it seems
How we might easily imagine
To this the other one responded: “You know that you have made a serious mistake and that I believe just the opposite. Now what I thought about him being the Son of God has been confirmed and my opinion has been vindicated. When I rid myself of human praise and self-love and permit myself to be guided by the spirit of our Master, which I feel within me, I will surely go to the city of Jerusalem to profess that Christ was the Son of God. If I were to be placed on the cross just as he was I would not be concerned, and you would see, as he himself said, si mundus vos odit, scitote quia me priorem vobis odio habuit.
5764 Hinc est, that there has never been a person who could equal Christ’s goodness and perfection because he was both God and man. Because he was opposed to them and audaciously uncovered the faults and sins of the leaders and the Pharisees whereas no one had ever opposed them so strongly, and this was why the disciples said that they imposed on him a most bitter death that was more abominable than any other person had ever endured.
Praeterea if you do not think that he was the Son of God go and read the Sacred Scriptures and see his teaching and you will not be able to find the slightest defective item as you will in other laws. Immo it is impossible to add the slightest thing to Christ’s laws or teachings that would improve them since everything is contained splendidly in the law of Christ.
Praeterea I cannot find anything that guarantees earthly things in Christ’s law. His way of life only guarantees toil and struggle. We note that he did not want to be born in circumstances of grandeur as the world sees it, but rather in a situation that was extremely poor. He never went after the pleasures of the senses because he always aspired to have the things of the spirit and of heaven. He taught the same thing to his disciples.
Praeteria we have seen how when they wanted to make him king, he did not want to accept it, because he said that his kingdom was not here.
Praeterea we can see that he did not seek the friendship of powerful people or of Lords so that he could become important but continually avoided them. Immo he reproved them for their faults most bitterly without showing any human respect. There were many other signs and all of them make me believe that he was the Son of God.” Let us take a short break.
5765 The first disciple answered: “You have expressed the truth very well; when you said that it would be great if he were the Son of God. However, I say that if he was not the Son of God, he was the wickedest and the most arrogant man that ever attempted to mislead and claim to be someone other than who he really was. Then what he had laid down could not last and we would soon see that he was not the Son of God and his teachings would be flung down on the ground. If indeed he was the Son of God, his teachings would be held in higher regard now that he was dead and increase in value every day. Then it might even have been possible for him to have risen as the women had reported.
To this the other disciple replied: “Oh, I think that you still have doubts. It appears to me to be very clear and certain that he was the Son of God. Tell me this. Have you forgotten how he predicted his Passion: Ecce ascendimus Hierosolimam et filius hominis tradetur principibus sacerdotum et scribis et condemnabunt eum morte et tradent eum gentibus ad illudendum et flagellandum et crucifigendum et tertia die resurget?
5766 Praetera, where could I find a person in whom all the symbols and prophesies in Sacred Scripture are fulfilled? It appears to me that they were certainly not fulfilled in anyone but Christ. What they contain applies to him. It begins with Abraham of whom it was said: In semine tuo benedicentur omnes gentes.
However, more than anything else what makes me believe is that I cannot find any other person in the Old Testament, including Abel, whom God commended for his innocence when offering a good and perfect sacrifice. Noah too was commended for his modesty, Abraham for his faith, Isaac for his obedience, Jacob for his ability to be caring, Joseph for his dreams, Moses for his prayer, Aaron for his implementation of God’s word, David for his prophesising, Solomon for his charity, Judas Maccabeus for his honesty, St John the Baptist for his works of penance and so on with all the other holy fathers who excelled in one or other of the virtues. However, with respect to our Master if you think about these virtues or any virtues you will find that they existed to the highest degree in Christ and immo more abundantly that ever.
5767 Do you want to see an even greater sign that is very exalted and sublime and that was proclaimed by both God and the whole of creation? The most prominent sign was his conception which was miraculous with God sending an Angel to announce a great mystery. His conception was not like the conception of other human beings. He started to receive adulation while in his Mother’s womb, when our Lady went up into the mountains of Galilee and Elizabeth felt St John, who was in her womb, praise and adore the Son of God. Elizabeth burst out into joyful song and Zachary, who had been unable to speak for some time, had his tongue unbound and said: Benedictus Dominus Deus Israel, quia visitavit et fecit redemptionem plebis suae.
Look at him then when he was born, the Angels sangg: Gloria in excelsis Deo.
5768 Not only his disciples but even those who were distressed and those who were persecuting him were forced to admit that he was God and that he possessed greater power than human power. This is why the Pharisees said: Si dimittimus eum sic, omnes credent in eum.
Pilot also recognised that he was the Son of God. Because of this he made many attempts to set him free. If Christ had said just one word, he would have freed him. Therefore, when he could go no further, he said: Innocens ego sum a sanguine iusti huius.
After Christ had died I hear the Centurion saying: Vere Filius Dei erat iste.
[Christ the pilgrim]
5769 Et factum est dum fabularentur et se componerent.
Christ replied: “What have you to say about Jesus of Nazareth?” They said: “That he was a great prophet in what he said and did and that he was condemned to death by the high priests and leaders and they crucified him when we had hoped that he would have redeemed Israel and three days have passed since this happened and he has still not risen. It is true that our women said that they went to the tomb and they met Angels who told them that he had actually risen.
5770 Under the disguise of a pilgrim Christ replied to these words: O stulti et tardi corde ad credendum in omnibus quae locuti sunt prophetae! Nonne oportuit Christum pati et ita intrare in gloriam suam?
As they approached the village of Emmaus he pretended to want to go further on so as to arouse them a little more. However, charmed by his sweet words and teaching the two disciples, coegerunt illum, politely put pressure on him saying: Mane nobiscum, Domine, quoniam advesperascit, et inclinata est iam dies.
5771 Note that Christ has assumed the appearance of a pilgrim and this would mean that he should rise early to go on with his journey.
A pilgrim will still go through Venegia and look at the palaces, the temples and other things of beauty. However, he does not stop but continues on his journey. Thus, he does not want to become a person of some repute, or laden with treasures, but to remain poor and abject with just the minimum for survival. So too the spiritual creature, even if he is possesses worldly wealth, honours and status, is not concerned about that or any created thing, but moves along life as very fast river, not being worried about his own welfare but about giving glory to God as the one who is the Creator of all, delaying at nothing so as to reach his objective that is God.
Praeterea, if he is injured or receives a knock the pilgrim does not seek revenge, because he is not in his homeland and is not stopping here but passing through. The same may be said of Christ. He was more hurt, offended and cast aside than any pilgrim and yet, like an angel, taking holy revenge with great meekness, humility and sweet words, he prayed to his Father for his enemies, for those who crucified him.
Even when he has been offended the spiritual creature likewise should not be vindictive. He should not be sensitive about the offenses except in so far as he recognises that they are an offense against God. Out of love of God he should banish all hatred and anger from his heart. He should exercise charity towards everyone and love them in Christ as members of the Church Militant.
In this way you will be imitating Christ the pilgrim who when the two disciples prevailed upon him to stay with them for the evening meal remained seated at the table. When he blessed the bread, as was his custom, he broke it and passed it round and then their eyes were opened, and they recognised who he was. Christ then disappeared from them. This amazed them and they began to say to one another: Nonne cor nostrum ardens erat in nobis, dum loqueretur in via?
[Conclusion: “Foolish ones and slow of heart”]
5772 “Oh how foolish was our intellect and how sluggish was our heart in not recognising him? Oh how our heart burnt at his sweet words?” They got up rapidly from the table and returned to the Holy City and went in search of the eleven Apostles and told them whom they had met. The eleven said the same thing that Christ had truly risen and had appeared to Peter.
My Vinegia, whoever is in love with Christ does not care about anything as long as he possesses him. Look at these two disciples: having got up from table they did not care about the evening meal and forgetting about themselves they ran to Jerusalem. Look at the Samaritan woman, because of the little bit of enlightenment she experienced in a flash concerning Christ, she left the well and the ropes and ran into Samaria so that the entire city hastened to pay honour to Christ, to recognise Christ and to believe in Christ.
So all the eleven said together: O stulti et tardi corde ad credendum!
Later they all said: “Oh how foolish was Judas to think that his sin was greater than God’s mercy,
5773 They said: Nonne cor nostrum erat ardens in nobis,
You too, beloved soul, should say: “Nonne cor nostrum ardens erat in nobis? Oh how I ought to be on fire when you showed me yesterday what a gift, what a treasure you who are God have given to my soul in giving me yourself as food, and in giving me the knowledge and the enlightenment of how to repent of my sins before I die?” Perhaps someone who has received communion has already begun to enter the night of the wretchedness of sin! This is the space that you create between yourselves and God through your emotions. My Venegia, do not let this happen to you. Rather chew, ruminate and consider the many gifts that you have received from God. As you read in the old law animals that did not chew the cud were unclean,
- That was Easter Monday (lundí dell’ Angelo = Angel’s Monday) which in 1539 fell on 7th April. ↑
- The Gospel about the disciples on the road to Emmaus: Lk 24:13-35. ↑
- Lk 24:35 ↑
- Note the progressive development of thought which suggests how to make a meditation in order to come to know the loving God, as he will explain later. ↑
- Lk 2:19 ↑
- Giotto in the text = ghiotto, goloso. ↑
- Acasca in the text = succeed, accade ↑
- Lk 24:14 ↑
- Here begins the conversation between the two as Ochino imagined it. One believed that Christ on the cross was the Son of God and the other did not. The disciple who believed this almost anticipates the explanation given by Christ. ↑
- Jn 15:18 ↑
- Jn 3:19 ↑
- Jn 6:15; 18:36 ↑
- Cf. Lk 24:22-23 ↑
- Mt 20:18 ↑
- Jn 8:59 ↑
- Gen 22:18; 26:4 ↑
- Ps 131:11 (Vulg.) ↑
- Is 7:14 ↑
- Mt 5:2; Mt 2:6 ↑
- Lk 1:68 ↑
- Lk 2:14 ↑
- Lk 16:16 ↑
- Mt 15:22 ↑
- Mt 8:8 ↑
- Jn 4:29 ↑
- Mt 3:17; 1 Pt 1:17 ↑
- Jn 1:49 ↑
- Jn 11:48 ↑
- Jn 11:50 ↑
- Mt 27:24 ↑
- Mt 27:19 ↑
- Mt 27:4 ↑
- Lk 23:42 ↑
- Lk 23:47 ↑
- Cf. Mt 27:51-53 ↑
- Lk 24:15 ↑
- Lk 24:17 ↑
- Lk 24:18 ↑
- Lk 24:19-24 ↑
- Lk 24:25-26 ↑
- Ochino abbreviates things here because he had already put many of these prophesies on the lips of one of the two disciples. ↑
- Lk 24:27-29 ↑
- Compare this parallel between a pilgrim and the Christian soul with what Ochino wrote in Dialogo VII where he is speaking about a “pilgrimage”. Cf above nn. 4081-4093 ↑
- Lk 24:30-31 ↑
- Lk 24:34 ↑
- Jn 4:28-29 ↑
- Lk 24:25 ↑
- Jn 14:8 ↑
- Cf. Jn 6:9 ↑
- Cf. Mt 20:20-22 ↑
- He has joined together the events narrated by the Gospel: Lk 8:23-25; Mt 8:24-27; Mk 4:36-43; Jn 21:7 ↑
- Cf. Mt 27:3-5 ↑
- Cf. Lk 22:61-62; Jn 21:15-19 ↑
- Lev 11:2ss; Dt 14: 4ss ↑