15. Sermon preached in Vinegia on the Feast of St Mary Magdalene 1539
By Bernardino Ochino da Siena
Translated by Patrick Colbourne OFM Cap
Translator’s note: This translation is based on the introduction, text and footnotes which were published by P. Costanzo Cargnoni O.F.M. Cap. In I Frati Cappuccini: Documenti e testimonianze dell primo secolo, Edizioni Frate Indovino, Perugia, vol III/1, pp.2290-2306. The only additions to the notes made by the translator are references to Francis of Assisi: The Early Documents, edited by Regis Armstrong, O.F.M. Cap., J. A. Wayne Hellmann, O.F.M. and William J. Short O.F.M. Conv., New York City Press, New York, London, Manila, for an English version of quotations from the Writings or Biographies of St Francis.
Introduction by Costanzo Cargnoni OFM Cap
Bernardino Ochino delivered a sermon in Venice on 22nd July 1539 in which he commented on the passage in the Gospel that speaks of the repentant woman whom he identified as Mary Magdalene. When speaking about Mary Magdalene who was a repentant woman and a contemplative, he developed the notion of how a soul can find spiritual peace and quiet during life on earth. He dealt with it by composing an imaginary conversation at court between a noble Lord who presents the topic and some wise courtesans who say that peace comes about from calming down the senses, the knowledge of God and heavenly things, listening to a fervent evangelical preacher, the practice of charitable works, conversion to Christ Crucified, sincere sorrow for personal sin and the contemplation of Christ crucified.
The proof for reaching this conclusion is attributed to the repentant woman when she responds to the question put to her by the noble Lord. The reply is exemplified by describing the personal experience of Mary Magdalene. She found peace not so much in superficial considerations “but in the experience of tears”, that is, in crying over her own sins “at the feet of Christ”. Only after this purification of the heart was she able to contemplate God and Christ’s Passion.
Ochino said that this sermon was specifically aimed at women who wished to imitate Mary Magdalene in her conversion leaving lust aside to undertake charitable works for the poor and for orphans.
15. Sermon preached in Vinegia on the Feast of St Mary Magdalene 1539 [1]
5796 When reading the Holy Gospels, I discovered that Christ gave St John the Baptist the highest praise
[The sinful woman who was forgiven: a complex exegesis]
Christ said that the sinful woman, Magdalene, made him very happy. You know that it is not easy to understand this Gospel passage, immo it is very hard to grasp its meaning. Nevertheless, I want to discover what it means (a little silence, please)
[A conversation “at court” about what gives the greatest peace on earth]
5797 Christ, to whom all the secrets of our heart are open, answered him: “There was a gentleman who
Note how it was not enough for Christ to name her, but he also became her advocate. The Pharisee should have loved Christ much more than she loved him, since the sinful woman only had about fifty sins, whereas the Pharisee had five hundred.
5798 There is another explanation that has a different meaning. Someone might say: Magdalene’s sins were greater. This might be true. However, I would go even further and say that if the Pharisee had no sins, he would be more obliged to love God because God had prevented him from committing sin. As St Augustine says, on the cross Christ not only forgave our sins, verum etiam all the countless sins that we could have committed but did not commit because we were prevented by the grace of God. There were many sins that could be committed in the future but God out of his pure simple generosity preserves us from committing them, because left to ourselves we would have nothing but sin and would deserve hell a thousand times. If we have been protected from this, we should love him all the more.
However, to give a more simple and pure interpretation and to adhere to Christ’s words in the Gospel,
Turning to Magdalene Christ said: Remittuntur ei peccata multa, quoniam dilexit multum. Remittuntur ei peccata sua,
5799 Once upon a time there was a noble Lord who was rich, powerful and gifted, surrounded with beautiful things, kept company with virtuous people and abounded in pleasures. One day he went out to spend free time with his courtiers and experienced great joy of soul and great peace and contentment of mind. Because of this he said to his companions: “I would like to know what it is that could give a person the most happiness in this life. I do not mean when he is in his heavenly homeland, since that pertains to God and consists in the clear vision of God. We are not talking about that now. I am only talking about our life as it is now. Where can we find our contentment and peace?”
One of his servants replied: “I will tell you, my Lord, what that is. You know that what causes our senses to enjoy peace and quiet is to feed and nourish them on the object of each one of them. For the eyes that is beauty and colour. For hearing it is sound, music and harmony. For the taste it is sweetness that satisfies the appetite. The same goes for all the other senses since each one of our faculties has its own object. Each of them acquires peace and contentment and discovers happiness and joy. As for you, my Lord, because you have concerned yourself in these days with satisfying all your appetites you have become very happy and contented.”
Another one said: “I believe that the way to achieve this is by means of the simple knowledge of God and of heavenly things, because it is in the source of truth that we come to know all truth. This is so because we dwell in the prison of the body, and due to sin this prison is dark and obscure and we cannot see the light of truth except the little bit that enters through the windows of our senses. This was not the way it was in the state of innocence, because even though mankind was still in the prison of the body his prison was open to things above him. He knew God and loved him and through this he understood other truths, a condition that sin took away from him, and consequentially he could not be at peace or be happy until the knowledge of God had been restored to him. In the meantime, the Prophet says: Liquefacta est anima mea.
5800 A third one said: “This is not the answer. I believer that you need an evangelical preacher
Someone else said: “This is not the cause. I will tell you what it is. I believe with certainty that an act of kindness towards one’s neighbour that is performed out of charity is more meritorious and pleasing to God than anything else that you could do. This is why when you do this it makes you feel so happy. Remember what Christ said: Quod uni ex minimis meis fecistis, mihi fecistis.
5801 Someone else replied: “I have another opinion. Nothing can give a person greater peace than coming back to God and being truly sorry for his sins. Worms have been eating into his fearful conscience. While a person is in the state of sin, he will enjoy no rest. He will never be at peace. He will always be anxious, afraid and worried about God’s judgement. He will be consumed
The last one said: “Neither is this the cause. The only cause is the sight of Christ hanging on the cross for us. In this vision when it is viewed with the eyes of the heart through faith, you can see the extent of his ardent love for us by being both God and man and becoming our brother, dressing in our flesh, sharing in what we suffer and being persecuted, enduring so much anxiety and persecution in this world for thirty years and, finally, in order to repay our debt, ascending the cross to wash us, save and cleanse us with his blood. If a creature considers this ardently, he will clearly know the intimate charity of God, which did not stop at giving him existence but went further by creating him in his image and likeness. This was not all. He governed him, guarded him and preserved him from sin and gave him so many gifts every day, ultimately offering himself on the cross when he could not give any thing more, to repay our debt. Thus, the soul will feel inflamed with love and feelings of genuine gratitude towards Christ. It will decide to love no one but Christ on the cross because he has been so sweet in dealing with him. Therefore, my Lord, seeing that you have been given these days to contemplate Christ for a longer time than usual, you should feel at peace, happy and joyful.”
Now let us take a break and then see
[The comments of the sinful woman]
5802 While this nobleman was out walking at leisure, he came across a cave where there was a woman whose only clothing was her hair and who was alone. The place is called La Baume, near Marseille and I have been there.
The first thing I have to say is that sensuality will not give you this because I believe that there has never been, nor will there be, any woman in the world that you could imagine who was as sensual as I was. This is because a woman like that turns her back on God, and turns to the world, no longer keeping God before her eyes, but looking at what is futile and delighting in it and thus becoming a shameful person, without respect or concern for anyone.
5803 Even if someone pays no attention to God, they might have a father and mother and will not do anything bad out of respect for them and not to embarrass them. This was not how it was with me. Not only had I no thought for God but I had no father or mother whom I had to consider. If someone has no father or mother and no possessions, she might be constrained by what she needs and not think about some things being worthless. However, I was wealthy, noble, young and beautiful. You should know that it is dangerous just to look at a woman even if you do not take her. I was not satisfied with being beautiful. I had to artificially decorate and redecorate myself. I bathed and bathed again. I probed and prodded. I scraped and scraped again. I used one kind of finery and then another. I tried one kind of tan and then another. One day I tried one style and tried a different one the next. I tried so many shades of red, tints, perfumes, solutions, milk mixtures, (You know, my lady, although these are not like the laws of Scotus you seem to be amazed that I know something about all of them.)
In the end I was not happy, because the more use I made of my senses, the more I desired to possess the objects of the senses. On the other hand, I never found myself at peace since I continually felt myself being eaten up with shame or human respect or the fear of hell, or thinking about death, or thinking about some weakness so that I was never satisfied.
5804 As far a coming to know God, I tried to do this. I wanted to force myself to understand the truth. However, our intellect does not go that far because it is incapable of reaching such heights and comprehending such goodness. After my conversion I experienced some such delight. You certainly come to know that this does not make us happy.
A person is not made happy by hearing the word of God even it if preached by an evangelical preacher not even when it is taught by those who are saints. He needs to hear the voice of Christ, the Son of the living God. For some time, this nourished me, satisfied and instructed me. However, I did not feel happy.
Not even acts of mercy were enough to make me feel peaceful, even when I performed them not just for the poor, but for Christ himself who I welcomed into my home as a guest, together with his disciples and the Madonna more than once. Then, in the Pharisee’s house, at the end of his life I anointed him with precious oil. However, this did not bring me peace. When I returned to God, repenting of my sins and being sorry for them because I had offended him, and Christ said to me: Remittuntur tibi peccate tua,
As to what you said about gazing on Christ on the cross making a person blessed, I say: that I saw him placed on the cross with my material eyes, and was present together with his Mother, when he was crucified between two thieves, and yet I did not feel contented.
Let me stop for a while and then continue. I have a strong recommendation for those who have been converted. They are standing at the door. I make this recommendation as strongly as I can.
[The greatest peace on earth is to be found in “tears of joy”]
5805 This holy penitent, this woman who had lived such a lax life and who had changed from being very lustful to being perfect, said that our happiness does not come about for any of these things, but that real happiness came from shedding tears.
However, you know that there are many kinds of tears. Some come about through being afraid, others through being compassionate. I am not talking about these kinds of tears, but about tears of joy. These are sweet, tender and make me rejoice and when I saw the love that God had for me, and that he sent his only Son to save me and to make me his spouse I was moved to be inflamed with lively ardent love for I realise that I had been in the darkness of sin and in the clutches of Lucifer. One day while I was where Christ was preaching I stood up in the middle of the sermon so that everyone would see me and say, “Look at the beautiful woman,” and then I sat myself down at the feet of Christ.” There she remained jus like you women who are in front of the preacher with the men behind you and I see that there are no men that steal your place or take away what is yours.
What he said was so effective that I was converted in a flash, just as Peter was converted by a single glance after he had denied Christ. Take note, my city that a sinner who has turned away from sin is like a bow. While you have your hand on the bow the arrow will do nothing in your hand. However, when you take your hand away the arrow will fly away in a circle and pierce something that is far away.
5806 However, when this women who had sinned followed Christ the preacher and gazed on him with her eyes, she like Magdalene became totally enflamed with love for him, to such an extent that she no longer valued pleasure, was no longer contented with worldly things or vanity or lust but was only concerned with being sorry for her sins. We can easily believe that when she returned home she took all of her decorations, makeup, wigs, perfume and the like and spread them out before herself before burning them, and that she said: “Oh my vanity, which could have sent me to the depths of hell and through which I have been the cause of the fall of many poor souls by giving bad example and provoking so much evil, I do not want to love you any longer or to take pleasure in you. I just want to love only my Christ and to praise him: Vulnerasti me in uno oculorum tuorum.
She went to the Pharisee’s house to cry over her sins at the feet of Christ. Thus you always picture Magdalene at the feet of Christ. She is at his feet when he is preaching. In the Pharisee’s house she is at his feet. In her own home she is at his feet. At the cross she is at his feet. At the grave she is at his feet. Wherever you meet her she is always crying.
[The contemplation of Mary Magdalene]
5087 This is the sinful woman that the Church Militant is presenting to you today. She had been the most lustful and sensuous woman that you could find in this world but is now presented as a mirror and norm for all penitents. She spent thirty-two years in the grotto at Bauma, where I have been with a friend and where I have celebrated Mass. There is a small church there in which there is a wooden image of Magdalene with a sign that reads: Non desperetis vos, qui peccare soletis, exemploque meo, vos praeparate Deo.
It is certainly a place where there is as much devotion as I have seen anywhere. By way of a miracle my companion received a marvellous gift concerning which he said: “Oh happy sins of Magdalene.” In this place there is an embankment nevertheless oozes water.
5808 Magdalene stayed here in such a state of penance that she did not care about any other food than crying and contemplating God. Seven times a day she was lifted up in spirit by angels. When it was time for Matins, she contemplated on how Christ was arrested and bound by the Jews, sold and tortured. This made her spirits wilt and angels came to lift her up and comfort her. When the hour of Prime arrived, she saw Christ being falsely accused in Pilate’s house, struck, bound and spat on. Then her strength failed her, and angels came and lifted her up consoling her with heavenly pleasures. At the hour of Terse Christ appeared dressed in purple, with a crown of thorns on his head, and with the cross on his shoulder. This wore her out with sorrow for her spouse. However, the angels returned and nourished her with divine love. At the hour of Sext she saw Christ on the cross between two thieves, exhausted and afflicted by torments and given vinegar and gall to drink. At this she felt as if she would faint but, at God’s command, angels came to support her during such sorrow. At None she thought about when Christ died, and his side was opened and out from it sprang the Church Militant. She felt that she would faint with joy, but the angels supported her. At the time for Vespers she considered how Christ was taken down from the cross. Finally, at the time for Compline she thought of how Christ was placed in the grave and she felt like fainting but the angels came to comfort her.
[Final exhortation to the women]
5809 Ladies, this sermon is just for you so I hope that as you have imitated Magdalene in your pomp and vanity you will imitate her in your conversion. As yet, I can say that the word of God has been wasted if it has not produced the fruit of conversion. You are women who belong to the nobility and I can tell that it does not become you to be taken up with such nonsense, because from a noble heart like yours one expects generosity and not what village and lower class women do.
“Oh, you might say, I do it to please my husband!” If you are doing it for your husbands, forget about it tonight and make me very happy. As for you, my good men, if your women are beautiful and well-breed, why are you not satisfied with them instead of going to prostitutes who might have satisfied you when your were in the army among soldiers and had no women. Each one of you is married and has companionship and so be satisfied with that.
5810 Ladies after you have cast off all pomp, three or four or six of you should gather together in a corner and keep company with Christ, being filled with love.
You ought to do something like this as penance for your sins.
Therefore, I exhort you and beg of you to undertake genuine amendment through doing voluntary penance, being deeply sorry for your sins and making firm and holy resolutions so that from now on you will be happy here and later on live in paradise.
- Tuesday 22nd July 1539 ↑
- In the text te commenda instead of commanda ↑
- Cf. Mt 11:11 ↑
- Jn 1:47 ↑
- Mt 8: 0 ↑
- Lk 18:14 ↑
- Mt 15:28 ↑
- Lk 7:47 ↑
- This shows that the sermon was being copied down while he was speaking. ↑
- This is the classical way of contrasting the clerical state with lay state. ↑
- Cf. Lk 7:39 ↑
- In the text chi instead of che ↑
- Lk 7:43 ↑
- Cf. Lk 7:44-46 ↑
- Lk 7:47 ↑
- The text has 500 ↑
- Note how his exegesis takes stock of the time and the purpose of “gospel preaching”. ↑
- Lk 7:39 ↑
- In the text nelle instead of dei ↑
- Cf. Lk 7:41 ↑
- Cf. Lk 7:47-48 ↑
- There is a great debate about whether there were three or less penitent women each one of whom was called Mary. Modern exegesis considers that this incident belongs to Luke alone, and is a different episode from what took place at Bethany (Mt 25:6-13). The sinful woman here is not to be identified with Mary from Bethany, Martha’s sister, or with Mary Magdalene. ↑
- Cf. S. Gregorio M., Ep. 25 ad Gregoriam (PL 77, 877s). ↑
- Cant. 5:6 ↑
- Note the description of an “evangelical preacher that is similar to the thinking of the early Capuchins. Cf. Const. 1536 nn. 111-121 ↑
- Desideraressemo = non desiderermmo ↑
- Cf. Mt 4:4; Lk 4:4; Dt 8:3; Wis 16:26 ↑
- Cf. Heb 4:12 ↑
- Mt 25:40 ↑
- Mt 25:35 ↑
- Divorono in the text = divorano ↑
- He is saying: Let us take a short break and then we shall continue the explanation. ↑
- It seems that Ochino was never in France while he was a Capuchin, at least not while he was General. Concerning the grotto called “La Beaume” near Marseille and the legend of Mary Magdalene the penitent see Philippus a Firenze, Itinera ministri generalis Bernardi ab Arezzo (1691-1698). II: Per Galliam, a cura di Mariano D’Alatri (MHOC XII), Romae 1968, 175ss. ↑
- We are amazed indeed at all that goes into making a woman beautiful. Ochino may have picked up such detailed knowledge while studying medicine in Perugia. ↑
- This is perhaps a reference to Dan 1:5, 15. ↑
- Cf. Eccl. 2:10 ↑
- Cf. Lk 7:48 ↑
- At the break the preacher is recommending that a collection be taken up at the door to support the charitable works in the city. ↑
- This is an interesting example. ↑
- He may have seen this during the time he spent at court in Petrucci. ↑
- Cf. Song 4:9. ↑
- It is interesting to observe the motives for these tears of sorrow and of love that provide evidence of conversion. This topic, among others, was very dear to the early Capuchins as a way of saying goodbye to the world and it was full of ascetical and mystical significance. ↑
- This is a splendid picture of Magdalene and it made an impression on many people including Victoria Colonna. ↑
- These are two events in the life of Christ that are not contained in the Gospel. They come from Meditationes vitae Christi which was mistakenly attributed to Bonaventure or from other works like that. ↑
- In the text mastella – mascella. ↑
- This is another apocryphal event. ↑
- This saying was coined by Virgil, Eneide, 630. “When I come to know the mishap, I share in the unhappiness.” ↑
- Note the testimony of an eyewitness. Cf. F. Benoit, Le culte de Marie Madelenine, in Annales du Midi 71 (1959) 278-282; V. Saxer, Maria Madallena, in Bibl. Sanctorum VIII, Romae 1967, 1078-1104 (bibliogr.) ↑
- This suggests a way of meditating on Christ’s passion during the liturgical hours which at the time was widely practiced as a devotional exercise. Giovanni da Fano, Verucchino and many others speak about it. It was in general use among the early Capuchins. ↑
- That is women of reprehensible behaviour. ↑
- In the text De gli non tanti lisci. ↑
- In the text the words onesta and modesta are us to create the effect of a rhyme. ↑
- Ochino is suggesting establishing a confraternity for the poor as a charitable work. ↑
- Ochino preached in Florence in 1538 after he had preached in Lucca. The identity of the kind “old lady” is not known. ↑
- Note how Ochino suggests becoming involved in works of charity as penance for sin in preference to engaging in corporal ascetical practices. ↑